SurVILEvor Island

In 2012, a number of villains with past histories fighting the Manhunter from Mars in various capacities were selected for a special poll of this blog's readership. Essentially, these were characters whose appropriateness to be grouped as part of the Martian Manhunter's rogues gallery was called into question, and put to a vote across thirteen day/hour/minute cycles. The conceit was that Despero, who had won that year's March Madness contest, was judging the worthiness of villains who had been treated here as Manhunter foes; with those rejected in that capacity expelled from a game show island inhabited by The Vile Menagerie. Those who remained after voting would constitute a stronger, more "pure" rogues gallery, firmly associated as anti-Alien Atlas adversaries.

• Asmodel was exiled by 63% of 16 votes.
• Brimstone was exiled by 64% of 25 votes.
• Cabal outplayed with 67% of 15 votes.
• Darkseid was exiled by 68% of 22 votes.
• Despero outfought at 92% of 25 votes.
• Doctor Light was exiled by 60% of 27 votes.
• Doctor Trap outfoxed 60% of 10 votes.
• Doomsday was exiled by 70% of 20 votes.
• Effigy outshined by 62% of 13 votes.
• Fernus outburned by 81% of 16 votes.
• Gorilla Grodd evened out at 50% of 26 votes.
• The Hyperclan outperformed by 94% of 15 votes.
• Kanto was exiled by 54% of 13 votes.
• Korge outraged by 83% of 12 votes.
• Libra was exiled by 78% of 18 votes
• Lobo was exiled by 78% of 23 votes.
• Mister Bones was exiled by 60% of 15 votes
• Mongul outsized at 62% of 26 votes.
• Professor Amos Fortune was exiled by 67% of 18 votes.
• Professor Hugo outwitted by 100% of 19 voters.
• Professor Ivo outlasted at 57% of 14 votes.
• Rott was 50% split by 10 votes.
• Triumph outvexed by 90% of 10 votes.
• Vandal Savage outlived by 53% of 19 votes.
• Weapons Master was exiled by 58% of 12 votes.

Exiled parties will largely be left out of Vile Menagerie games, whether it be themed events, banners, biographical entries, further elimination contests like March Madness and Legions of Doom, or whatever else we can devise for the true, confirmed rogues gallery of the Sleuth from Outer Space.